Jürgen Elsässer (born 1957) is a journalist, publicist and activist. In 2009 he founded the “popular initiative against finance capital”, one of the most powerful circles of the New Right. Since 2010 he has been editor-in-chief of Compact Magazin, one of the most important media for the New Right.
Random Quotes
Wrong!
Unfortunately wrong answer.
Try again!
The answer was
OK
I am German and I do not want to accept that our beautiful Germany, our freedom and even our humanity goes to the dogs. And she will go to the dogs if we don’t drive this gang that holds the state in its claws and torments the people to the devil. When the government locks the people up. Then the people must lock up the government.
Correct!
I am German and I do not want to accept that our beautiful Germany, our freedom and even our humanity goes to the dogs. And she will go to the dogs if we don’t drive this gang that holds the state in its claws and torments the people to the devil. When the government locks the people up. Then the people must lock up the government.
Year:
Author Bio:
Source:
speech on April 15, 2021 in Berlin.
Context:
In 2014 and 2015 he appeared as a spokesman for the Pegida movement, in 2020 and 2021 for the lateral thinking movement. He openly represents cross-hostile, racist and sexist narratives and regularly uses conspiracy myths in his arguments.
Further Reading:
OK
We wanted lasting peace, true democracy and justice. But after only a few months we had to realise that our hopes had not been fulfilled. Therefore we returned to the mountains to continue the struggle for the liberation of our country.
Correct!
We wanted lasting peace, true democracy and justice. But after only a few months we had to realise that our hopes had not been fulfilled. Therefore we returned to the mountains to continue the struggle for the liberation of our country.
Year:
Author Bio:
Remedios Gomez-Paraiso (1919-2014) was a commander of the anti-Japanese Hukbalahap People’s Liberation Army in the Philippines during World War II. Here about the “liberation” and reoccupation of the Philippines by the USA in 1944.
Source:
Rheinisches JournalistInnenbüro & Recherche International e.V. (2008): 100f.
Context:
The Philippines was a Spanish colony from 1571 until, as an outcome of anti-colonial liberation struggle, it declared independence in 1898. However, its independence was not recognised, and in the ensuing Philippine-American War of 1899 to 1902, a fifth of the population lost their lives. The islands then became a US colony until 1942 when they were occupied by Japanese troops. The Anti-Japanese People’s Liberation Army was the largest resistance movement in the Philippines and consisted of 30,000 fighters and 70,000 reservists. They collaborated with the US against the Japanese, but were a left-wing partisan group opposed to US colonial rule. According to writer Ricardo Trota Jose, 80% of Filipinos were either in the resistance or supported it ‘One million Filipinos fought in various guerrilla movements. The only problem was: there were not enough weapons. For twenty volunteers who went to the partisans, only one rifle came’ (rjb & ri 2008). The Philippines gained independence in 1946, but a US-friendly government was then installed. It was only in 1990, under President Corazon Aquino, that resistance fighters were finally recognised as such (Rheinisches Journalistenbüro & Recherche International 2008: 100f.).
Further Reading:
*Rheinisches JournalistInnenbüro & Recherche International e.V. (2008): Die dritte Welt im zweiten Weltkrieg. Unterrichtsmaterialien zu einem vergessenen Kapitel der Geschichte.
OK
The coloniser, who in order to ease his conscience gets into the habit of seeing the other man as an animal, accustoms himself to treating him like an animal, and tends objectively to transform himself into an animal. (…) They talk to me about progress, achievements, diseases cured, improved standards of living. I am talking about (…) development oriented solely toward the benefit of the metropolitan countries, about the looting of products, the looting of raw materials. They talk to me about civilisation. I talk about proletarianisation and mystification.
Correct!
The coloniser, who in order to ease his conscience gets into the habit of seeing the other man as an animal, accustoms himself to treating him like an animal, and tends objectively to transform himself into an animal. (…) They talk to me about progress, achievements, diseases cured, improved standards of living. I am talking about (…) development oriented solely toward the benefit of the metropolitan countries, about the looting of products, the looting of raw materials. They talk to me about civilisation. I talk about proletarianisation and mystification.
Year:
Author Bio:
Aimé Césaire (1913-2008) was an Afro-Caribbean French writer and politician, founder of the Negritude movement that sought to liberate Black people from colonial rule.
Source:
Aimé Césaire (1968/2000)
Context:
In his 1950 essay On Colonialism, from which this quote comes, Césaire denounced the fact that while colonialism feigned a desire to “civilise”, its real goal was always exploitation (1968: 8). Both the colonised and European proletarians, he wrote, had understood this long ago (1968: 6). Here, Césaire posited a problematic connection between the Holocaust and colonial genocide, writing that ‘what he [the European citizen] does not forgive Hitler [is] not the crime per se (…) but that it is a crime against white people’ (1968: 12). in a different vein, Michael Rothberg argues for a multidimensional culture of remembrance that does not set victims against each other. For an example of such a position, see the cooperation between Ibrahim Arslan, survivor of the racist arson attack in Mölln/Northwest Germany, and Ester Bejarano, Auschwitz survivor (Möllner Reden im Exil from 2013).
Further Reading:
*Aimee Césaire (2000): Discourse on Colonialism. A Poetics of Anticolonialism.
OK
If the judge has to individualise everywhere else, i.e. first investigate and get to know the peculiarities of the subject to be treated and then determine the course to pursue, the initiate can generalise on the nature of XXX without any danger.
Correct!
If the judge has to individualise everywhere else, i.e. first investigate and get to know the peculiarities of the subject to be treated and then determine the course to pursue, the initiate can generalise on the nature of XXX without any danger.
Year:
Author Bio:
From a text by the Princely Reuss-Plauenscher Criminal Counselor and head of the Princely Criminal Court in Lobenstein in Thuringia in the 19th century.
Source:
Klaus Michael Bogdal (2011): Europa erfindet die Zigeuner. Bonn: bpb, p. 279.
Context:
The first documented mentions of Sint*ezza and Romn*ja in today’s Germany are from the beginning of the 15th century. The ancestors of the Sint*ezza and Romn*ja who live in Europe today migrated from what are now India and Pakistan. Very soon after their arrival, the initial tolerance gave way to discriminatory practices and racist language. From early on, white Germans were given license to equate all Sint*ezza and Romn*ja as criminals, so that, for example, no evidence was required when Sint*ezza and Romn*ja were accused of a crime; they were treated as criminals by definition. Although they continue to be marginalised to this day, the Sint*ezza and Romn*ja have always been an integral part of social life, notwithstanding Nazi propaganda and until Chancellor Adolf Hitler came to power. Despite widespread resistance to their deportation, and within the death camps themselves, an estimated 500,000 Sint*ezza and Romn*ja fell victim to the Germans in the Porajmos, the genocide.
Further Reading:
*Ian Hancock (1987): The Pariah Syndrome. An Account of Gypsy Slavery and Persecution.
*Romani Phen: Romnja Archiv.
OK
“It is clear, then, that some men are by nature free, and others slaves, and that for these latter slavery is both expedient and right.”
Correct!
“It is clear, then, that some men are by nature free, and others slaves, and that for these latter slavery is both expedient and right.”
Year:
Author Bio:
Aristotele (384 BCE – 322 BCE), ancient philosopher, student at the Platonic Academy and tutor to Alexander at the court of King Philip, taught from 335/4 at the public gymnasium (Lykeion) in Athens and then founded his own school, later named after Peripathos.
Source:
Quote: Aristotele: Politics. Princeton: Princeton University Press, p. 1991, 1255a1–2.
Picture: Nach Lysipp – Jastrow (2006). Wikimedia. Creative Commons.
Context:
The quote comes from Aristotle’s first book of his “Politics”, in which he attempts to demonstrate the inequality of the distribution of power and the subordination and superiority of people as a natural fact. In response to the objection that prisoners of war could fall into slavery by chance without having previously been slaves, he argues that it is precisely in their defeat in battle that their previously hidden “slave nature” is revealed. Aristotle’s defense of the institution of slavery was a powerful source of justification for the conquerors, slaveholders and settlers of the pre-modern as well as the modern era.
Further Reading:
*New York Times (Agnes Callard, 21.07.2020): Should We Cancel Aristotle?
*Olivia Haynie (27.11.2022): Aristotle and the Argument for American Slavery, Penns.
OK
In all peoples in which Jews lived as tolerated or still live today, they turned out to be disruptors of inner peace and thus destroyers of national communities that had become natural. The Old Testament of the Bible, which the Jews claim contains their story, is at the same time the story of peoples who were materially and spiritually ruined by the Jews. However, the Jew has not shown himself to be the only disruptor of natural development in peoples. He is also the destroyer of peace among the peoples.
Correct!
In all peoples in which Jews lived as tolerated or still live today, they turned out to be disruptors of inner peace and thus destroyers of national communities that had become natural. The Old Testament of the Bible, which the Jews claim contains their story, is at the same time the story of peoples who were materially and spiritually ruined by the Jews. However, the Jew has not shown himself to be the only disruptor of natural development in peoples. He is also the destroyer of peace among the peoples.
Year:
Author Bio:
Julius Streicher (1885-1946)
Julius Streicher was editor of the anti-Semitic propaganda newspaper “Der Stürmer”, the leading anti-Semitic propaganda newspaper under National Socialism.
Source:
Julius Streicher, The Striker, October 17, 1940.
Context:
Joined ethnic movements at an early stage, he took part in the so-called Hitler Putsch in 1923, which earned him Hitler’s trust. After the transfer of power to the Nazis, Streicher was made head of the “Central Committee to Repel Jewish Atrocities and Boycotts”. In the Nuremberg trials, the court sentenced him to hang up for crimes against humanity in October 1946.
Further Reading:
https://www.bing.com/videos/search?view=detail&mid=C0BAED96B28B4212D5B3C0BAED96B28B4212D5B3&q=julius streicher&shtp=GetUrl&shid=7bb31e73-be37-42a1-854b-37eb59d99144&shtk=RGVyIEp1ZGVuaGV0emVyIC0gSnVsaXVzIFN0cmVpY2hlciBEb2t1IERldXRzY2g%3D&shdk=SnVsaXVzIFN0cmVpY2hlciAoKiAxMi4gRmVicnVhciAxODg1IGluIEZsZWluaGF1c2VuIGJlaSBBdWdzYnVyZzsg4oCgIDE2LiBPa3RvYmVyIDE5NDYgaW4gTsO8cm5iZXJnKSB3YXIgZWluIG5hdGlvbmFsc296aWFsaXN0aXNjaGVyIFBvbGl0aWtlci4gRXIgd2FyIEdyw7xuZGVyIC4gSnVsaXVzIFN0cmVpY2hlciAoKiAxMi4gSnVsaXVzIFN0cmVpY2hlciAoKiAxMi4gRmVicnVhciAxODg1IGluIEZsZWluaGF1c2VuIGJlaSBBdWdzYnVyZzsg4oCgIDE2LiBPa3RvYmVyIDE5NDYgaW4gTsO8cm5iZXJnKSB3YXIgZWluIG5hdGlvbmFsc296aWFsaXN0aXNjaGVyIFBvbGl0aWtlci4gRXIgd2FyIEdyw7xuZGVyIC4uLg%3D%3D&shhk=t0MSPrjlnhUkDL0PrUO%2FXvU5Z3bPC0wu%2FbkyoEr%2Bv%2Bc%3D&form=VDSHOT&shth=OVP.MYBgn_UkgM1sRSfEqVddSQEsDh
OK
We have given jobs to every family that has lost their homes and land to the Dock Complex.
Correct!
We have given jobs to every family that has lost their homes and land to the Dock Complex.
Year:
Author Bio:
M.L. Meena (birthdate unknown) was Deputy Chairman of the Haldia Dock Complex in Calcutta, India.
Source:
Quoted in Samata Biwas (2016): Haldia: Logistics and its Other(s). Workshop-paper Kolkata Research Group.
Context:
A lot of migration also takes place within states. When India freed itself from British colonial rule in 1947, the former colony was divided into the independent states of India and Pakistan. “For more than ten million people on both sides of the new border, this was tantamount to resettlement, flight and expulsion” (Federal Agency for Civic Education (2014): The Partition of British India 1947). Other forced migrations take place because of so-called development projects. The quote comes from the Kolkatta area of West Bengal, where many people were dispossessed for the construction of the dock and harbour complex. Many have been waiting for compensation for decades.
Further Reading:
*Samata Biswas (2017): Haldia, A Port City in India.
*Kalim Siddiqui (2012): Development and Displacement in India: Reforming the
Economy towards Sustainability.
OK
Once the Jews had emigrated, they could come into contact unhindered with their racial comrades from the rest of the world and do more damage to the deserted country than before. […] In addition, the Jews were getting closer to their goal of establishing a Jewish nation state” […]. I would like to allow myself to draw your attention to the fact that it would be very appropriate and more appropriate to prevent the Jews from emigrating from your country and to send them to where they are under strong control, e.g. to Poland. This avoids their danger and does a good, grateful deed towards the Arab people…
Correct!
Once the Jews had emigrated, they could come into contact unhindered with their racial comrades from the rest of the world and do more damage to the deserted country than before. […] In addition, the Jews were getting closer to their goal of establishing a Jewish nation state” […]. I would like to allow myself to draw your attention to the fact that it would be very appropriate and more appropriate to prevent the Jews from emigrating from your country and to send them to where they are under strong control, e.g. to Poland. This avoids their danger and does a good, grateful deed towards the Arab people…
Year:
Author Bio:
Palestine, Mohammed Amin Al-Husseini (1895-1974)
Al-Husseini was an Islamic clergyman and Palestinian Arab nationalist from one of Jerusalem’s most influential families. He became known as the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem.
Source:
Sönke Zankel: The Jew as Anti-Muslim. In: Niklas Günther, Sönke Zankel (Ed.): Abrahams Enkel. Stuttgart 2006, p. 48.
Context:
Amin al-Husseini played a decisive role in the spread of modern anti-Semitism in the Arab region and the cooperation between Islamist anti-Semites and the National Socialists. He was a staunch supporter of the extermination of European Jews in the German Reich and in the areas occupied by Germany. He made contact with the National Socialists, won support from German leadership circles and lived in Berlin from October 1941 until the end of the Second World War. During this time he became a member of the SS and carried out propaganda for Germany in Arabic. In the late stages of the World War, al-Husseini helped mobilize Muslims for the Waffen SS in the Balkans. After the war, al-Husseini was wanted as a war criminal in several European countries and handed over to the French authorities after his arrest in Switzerland. After France, England and the USA for strategic reasons refrained from indicting Husseini as a war criminal, he found asylum in Egypt in 1946, from where he pursued his ideas. As a result of the massive flight of Palestinians that began with the Palestinian War of 1948, he lost his political leadership position, which eventually passed to the PLO under Yasser Arafat.
Further Reading:
David Motadel – Für Prophet und Führer – die islamische Welt und das dritte Reich
OK
Brother and Captain Maharero! We would like to hear what your actual thoughts are on Palgrave’s intentions and his request that we enter into an alliance with him. We were pleased to hear that you too were completely opposed to entering into such an alliance with him. Now see, it is our firm resolve that we will keep our country and people, let it go as it will. (…) They try to keep us apart.
Correct!
Brother and Captain Maharero! We would like to hear what your actual thoughts are on Palgrave’s intentions and his request that we enter into an alliance with him. We were pleased to hear that you too were completely opposed to entering into such an alliance with him. Now see, it is our firm resolve that we will keep our country and people, let it go as it will. (…) They try to keep us apart.
Year:
Author Bio:
Moses Witbooi or ǀGâbeb ǃA-ǁîmab (c. 1807-1888) was a Nama captain in present-day Namibia. The quote is from a letter to the Ovaherero Captain Maharero ua Tjamuaha.
Source:
Heinrich Vedder (1931): Maharero und seine Zeit im Lichte der Dokumente seines Nachlasses. Windhoek: Veröffentlichungen der Wissenschaftlichen Gesellschaft für S.W. Afrika. Band V., p. 18.
Context:
The Roman strategy of divide and rule was used by the Germans in Namibia to ensure they would not face a united anti-colonial army. The Witbooi family led the Nama in the resistance against German colonial power. The Nama were attacked by the Germans in 1893, in what became known as the Hornkranz Massacre, in which most of their women and children were slaughtered, while male warriors escaped. Henrik Witbooi, Moose’s son, then led a guerrilla war. After several attempts, which the exchange of letters also bears witness to, from 1904 onwards, the Herero and Nama united their forces in resistance. They then succumbed to the colonial power and were interned in camps where most of the remaining Nama and Herero perished. Overall, it is estimated that between 1904 and 1908, up to 70,000 Nama and Herero died in what was the first genocide of the 20th century (Jorgensen & Markusen 1999: 288).
Further Reading:
*Reinhard Koesseler (2007): Genocide, Apology and Reparation – the linkage between images of the past in Namibia and Germany.
*is3w (2007): Altlasten – Namibias langer Weg in die Unabhängigkeit.
*Torben Jorgensen & Eric Markusen (1999): The Genocide of the Hereros. In: Israel W. Charny (Hrsg.): Encyclopedia of Genocide. Band 1, S. 288.
OK
“That’s how I felt too, except that you can’t show it to the outside world. They can’t make their pain and the reason for this pain, that it was forced sterilization, clear to the outside world. Because there is such a stigma attached to being forcibly sterilized as inferior, to being labeled as inferior for life. That’s an incredible thing. Just imagine if that were you!”
Correct!
“That’s how I felt too, except that you can’t show it to the outside world. They can’t make their pain and the reason for this pain, that it was forced sterilization, clear to the outside world. Because there is such a stigma attached to being forcibly sterilized as inferior, to being labeled as inferior for life. That’s an incredible thing. Just imagine if that were you!”
Year:
Author Bio:
Dorothea Buck (1917-2019) was a German author and sculptor. Under Nazi rule, she was classified as mentally ill and forcibly sterilized. She gave critical lectures, wrote essays and, among other things, a play about the hundreds of thousands of murders of mentally ill and disabled people during the Nazi era. In 1992, she founded the Bundesverband Psychiatrie-Erfahrener (Federal Association of People with Psychiatric Experiences) together with other people affected.
Source:
RBB, 27.05.2010:
Context:
During the Nazi regime, hundreds of thousands of people fell victim to human experimentation by doctors, as well as to inhumane medical treatment and the murder of the sick. The Nazis sought out their victims in psychiatric wards, concentration camps and prisoner-of-war camps. After the Nuremberg trials against the main war criminals, twelve follow-up trials were held between 1946 and 1949. In the doctors’ trial of 1946-1947, the American military court indicted 23 doctors, administrative staff and a lawyer on charges including Crimes against humanity. Seven of them were sentenced to death. The most famous war criminal, Joseph Mengele, camp doctor in Auschwitz 1943-1945, was never caught and died in a swimming accident in Brazil in 1979. For decades, victims of human concentration camp experiments on both sides of the Iron Curtain fought for compensation and recognition. Colonial injustices can also be identified here, as the Nazis saw their colonial project in Eastern Europe (Zimmerer 2003). After the war, Eastern European survivors were excluded from all benefits for a long time. “This only changed when international attention was drawn to the persecution of the group of Polish women who became known as the Ravensbrueck Lapins. Their case contributed significantly to the gradual softening of the radical exclusion of Eastern European victims of Nazi persecution” (Baumann 2009).
Picture: The bronze statue “Mother with Child” (Hamburg) created by Dorothea Buck.
Further Reading:
*Stefanie Michaela Baumann 2009: Human Experiments and Reparation: The Long Dispute over Compensation and Recognition of the Victims of National Socialist Human Experiments. Berlin, Boston, Oldenbourg: De Gruyter.
*Jürgen Zimmerer, Holocaust and Colonialism. Beitrag zu einer Archäologie des genozidalen Gedankens, in: Zeitschrift für Geschichtswissenschaft 51/2003, pp. 1098-1119, here p. 1102. His contributions on the question of continuity were published once again as ders, Von Windhuk nach Auschwitz? Contributions on the relationship between colonialism and the Holocaust, Berlin 2011.
OK
Among the savage nations of hunters and fishers, every individual who is able to work, is more or less employed in useful labour (…) Such nations, however, are so miserably poor that, from mere want, (…) to the necessity sometimes of directly destroying, and sometimes of abandoning their infants, their old people, (…) Among civilised and thriving nations, on the contrary, though a great number of people do not labour at all (…) yet the produce of the whole labour of the society is so great that all are often abundantly supplied.
Correct!
Among the savage nations of hunters and fishers, every individual who is able to work, is more or less employed in useful labour (…) Such nations, however, are so miserably poor that, from mere want, (…) to the necessity sometimes of directly destroying, and sometimes of abandoning their infants, their old people, (…) Among civilised and thriving nations, on the contrary, though a great number of people do not labour at all (…) yet the produce of the whole labour of the society is so great that all are often abundantly supplied.
Year:
Author Bio:
Adam Smith (1723-1790) was a Scottish moral philosopher and Enlightenment figure and is considered the founder of classical economics.
Source:
Adam Smith, Adam (1776): The Wealth of Nations. Book I, p.11.
Context:
The logic of European economic thinking evident in this quote was used to devalue social and economic systems on other continents and dismiss them as irrational. This argument was also used to legitimate the idea that they should be integrated into capitalism, apparently for their own benefit. The fact that non-capitalist societies found other values, such as equality or solidarity more important than the generation of income and profit (see the Southern African concept of Ubuntu) was not recognised. Nor was the fact that these values underlay a much more ecologically sustainable way of life.
Further Reading:
*Abeba Birhane (2017): Descartes was wrong: ‘a person is a person through other persons’.
* Piet J. Naudé (2010): “Fair Global Trade: A Perspective from Africa.” In: Geoff Moore, Fairness in International Trade. Durham: Springer‘s.
OK
Police come out to collect our rent. The Aboriginal‘s Protection Board think it is important for the coloured people to pay rent. But the white people never thought of paying US rent for the whole country that they took from our ancestors.
Correct!
Police come out to collect our rent. The Aboriginal‘s Protection Board think it is important for the coloured people to pay rent. But the white people never thought of paying US rent for the whole country that they took from our ancestors.
Year:
Author Bio:
Mary Clarke, (date of birth unknown – 1984) was a Koori Aboriginal activist. The quote comes from a speech recorded at a meeting with journalists. The meeting was organised to speak out against the eviction of a woman and her children of multiracial decent from their home in Framlingham Settlement, Victoria, Australia.
Source:
Original source: Newspaper Melbourse Argus (22.02.1951). Reprinted in: Jan Chritchett (1998): Untold Stories: Memories and Lives of Victorian Kooris. Melbourne: Melbourne University Press, p. 4.
Context:
Australia was one of Great Britain’s settler colonies. In 1770, James Cook claimed eastern Australia for the British Crown. He also put forward the idea of a prison colony to relieve overcrowded British prisons. In 1788, Captain Arthur Phillip landed in Sydney with 1,500 prisoners. It is estimated that between 1788 and 1900 up to 90% of Australia’s indigenous people were killed by introduced diseases, land dispossession and violent conflict. There were mass shootings, people were thrown in groups off cliffs or offered land poisoned with arsenic or other substances (Behrendt 2012: 274). George Reid, a politician from the Free Trade Party, said in an election speech in 1903 that ‘we should have a white Australia’ (he became Prime Minister in 1904). Forging a white Australia was a key political goal not only for him, however, but for European settlers in general over the centuries. The protests of the Aboriginal population also go back a long way. In 1938 a silent march was held to commemorate 150 years of land grabbing and colonization (creativespirits.info).
Further Reading:
*Foley, Gary (1999): ATSIC: Flaws in the Machine. The Koori History Website.
*John Harris (2003): Hiding the Bodies: the myth of the humane colonisation of Australia. In: Aboriginal History Journal. Canberra: Australian Centre for Indigenous History, S. 79-104.
*Larissa Behrendt (2013): Indigenous Australia for Dummies. Canberra: International Journal of Critical Indigenous Studies, S. 53f. (Rezension)
*creativespirits.info: Aboriginal timeline: Protest.
OK
“A man counts as a man in virtue of his manhood alone, not because he is a Jew, Catholic, Protestant, German, Italian, etc.”
Correct!
“A man counts as a man in virtue of his manhood alone, not because he is a Jew, Catholic, Protestant, German, Italian, etc.”
Year:
Author Bio:
Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel (1770-1831) was a philosopher of German Idealism.
Source:
Quote: Georg Friedrich Wilhelm Hegel (1896): Philosophy of Right, translated and first Published: S W Dyde, G Bell: London 1896.
Picture: Lazarus Gottlieb Sichling/ Nach Friedrich Julius Ludwig Sebbers – Wikimedia, Creative Commons.
Context:
In particular in his lectures, Hegel repeatedly makes racist arguments. He describes the inhabitants of the socalled sub-Saharan Africa as “a child nation”, who could “so easily be made into slaves” due to their lack of consciousness of personality. In the quote here, Hegel emphasizes that in modern bourgeois society all people are equal, regardless of religion or nationality. The condition for this, however, is that this legal equality must first be achieved historically. This idea harbors the possibility of devaluing other forms of life that do not correspond to the European, modern, bourgeois order as underdeveloped.
Further Reading:
*Jamila Mascat (2022): Race, Feminism and Critical Race Theories: What’s Hegel Got to Do with It?, in: Lettow, S., Pulkkinen, T. (eds.): The Palgrave Handbook of German Idealism and Feminist Philosophy. Palgrave Handbooks in German Idealism. Londing: Palgrave Macmillan, p. 329-349.
*Michael Hardimon (2024): Where Did Hegel Go Wrong on Race? Hegel Bulletin 45(1), p. 23-42.
OK
Most important of all (…) it is necessary to make some estimate of the number of people killed and injured so as to extract the millions who were taken alive and sound. The resultant figure would be many times the millions landed alive outside of Africa, and it is that figure which represents the number of Africans directly removed from the population and labour force of Africa because of the establishment of slave production by Europeans.
Correct!
Most important of all (…) it is necessary to make some estimate of the number of people killed and injured so as to extract the millions who were taken alive and sound. The resultant figure would be many times the millions landed alive outside of Africa, and it is that figure which represents the number of Africans directly removed from the population and labour force of Africa because of the establishment of slave production by Europeans.
Year:
Author Bio:
Walter Rodney (1942-1980) was a Marxist historian and politician from Guyana. Rodney was born into a working class family, studied in Guyana and Jamaica and taught in Hamburg and Tanzania, amongst other places. In 1980 he was killed in a bomb attack while campaigning for the Working People’s Alliance. In all likelihood, the then Forbes Burnham administration was responsible for the murder.
Source:
Walter Rodney (1973: 96)
Context:
Rodney claims that a) the transatlantic abduction and forced enslavement of millions of Africans to Europe and America, b) economic exploitation and c) political colonial power resulted in the systematic underdevelopment of Africa. His book was enormously influential in efforts to develop a new anti-colonial perspective within historiography. Rodney’s book concludes with the statement that the only humanistic way to liberate and develop Africa would be to end the neo-colonial regime.
Further Reading:
*Walter Rodney (1973): How Europe Underdeveloped Africa. London & Dar-Es-Salaam: Bogle-L’Ouverture Publications.
OK
Work never killed anybody, but through idleness people loose life and limb, because man was born to work like a bird was born to fly.
Correct!
Work never killed anybody, but through idleness people loose life and limb, because man was born to work like a bird was born to fly.
Year:
Author Bio:
Martin Luther (1483-1546) was a German monk and professor of theology. He was the most important figure in the Reformation which challenged the power of the Catholic Church.
Source:
Quote: Heinz-Josef Bontrup (2009): Arbeit und Kapital. Wirtschaftspolitische Bestandsaufnahme und Alternativen. In: Johannes Rehm / Hans G. Ulrich (Hrsg.): Menschenrecht auf Arbeit? Sozialethische Perspektiven, Stuttgart: Kohlhammer, p. 164.
Picture: Wikimedia.
Context:
Luther saw work as a form of service, stressing that both secular and spiritual professions were of equal value. Over the following centuries, the Protestant conception of work served as one of the ideological arguments for justifying the imprisonment in workhouses of those not considered hardworking. In Calvinism in particular, property and wealth were viewed as signs of divine pleasure. In The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism (1904/1905), the sociologist Max Weber described the close connection between the Protestant work ethic and capitalism.
Further Reading:
*BBC (27.03.2014): In Our Time. Weber’s The Protestant Ethic.
OK
There were 60,000 people living on this island, including the Indians; so that from XXXX to XXXX, over 3,000,000 people had perished from war, slavery, and the mines. Who in future generations will believe this? I myself writing it as a knowledgeable eyewitness can hardly believe it.
Correct!
There were 60,000 people living on this island, including the Indians; so that from XXXX to XXXX, over 3,000,000 people had perished from war, slavery, and the mines. Who in future generations will believe this? I myself writing it as a knowledgeable eyewitness can hardly believe it.
Year:
Author Bio:
Bartolomé de las Casas (1484-1566) was a member of the Dominican Order and active as a bishop in the Spanish colonies in America. The Valladolid dispute (1550-1551) between de las Casas and the philosopher Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda dealt with the question of the legitimacy of the enslavement of the indigenous population of America. Sepúlveda represented the interests of Spanish landowners, de las Casas pointed out the violent acts of the Spaniards. The missing dates are 1494 and 1508, a period of 14 years.
Source:
Howard Zinn (1980): The People’s History of The United States. New York: Harper Collins.
Context:
In the first century of America’s occupation, the population decreased by approximately 75 million (95% in some areas) as a consequence of imported disease and murder (Federici 2009: 85f.). As early as the 1560s, there were resistance movements against the Spaniards. For example, members of the Taki Onqoy movement (1560-1572), which arose in what is now Peru, were opposed to any cooperation with the Europeans and advocated an alliance of Andean indigenous peoples to end European colonisation. They rejected Christianity and Christian names as well as food or other consignments from the Spaniards, they paid no tribute and did not work for the conquerors (Stern 1982: 50ff.).
Further Reading:
*Steven J. Stern (1982): Peru‘s Indian Peoples and the Challenge of Spanish Conquest. Huamanga to 1640. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press, S. 50ff.
*Silvia Federici (2009): Caliban and the Witch. Women, the Body and Primitive Accumulation. New York: Autonomedia.
OK
After two weeks we were sent to the comfort station. It was a wooden barracks with up to six separate rooms (…). The rooms were tiny, with sheets and blankets on the wooden floors. Soldiers kept coming and going – even after midnight.
Correct!
After two weeks we were sent to the comfort station. It was a wooden barracks with up to six separate rooms (…). The rooms were tiny, with sheets and blankets on the wooden floors. Soldiers kept coming and going – even after midnight.
Year:
Author Bio:
Hwang Kum-Ju (born ca. in 1920) was a Korean forced into prostitution in a brothel for Japanese soldiers. She had been promised work in a factory, but was instead deported to Manchuria.
Source:
Quoted in Rheinisches JournalistInnenbüro; recherche international e.V. (2008: 111). Original from Hwang Kum-Ju (2002/2003): Script for the Korean Council for the rehabilitation for victims of violence during WWII as well as Interviews on 20.10.2002 and 03.12.2003, Seoul. The Year (2002) is an approximation.
Context:
Forced migration in Asia is often associated with Japanese colonial rule. By 1910, Korea had been fully colonised by Japan, with colonial rule ending in 1945 with the end of World War II and Japan’s surrender. During World War II, Korean women were abducted and enslaved as forced prostitutes for the Japanese army. According to estimates by Asian NGOs, between 1932 and 1945 the Imperial Japanese Army abducted a total of 200,000 women from Korea, China, the Philippines, Malaya, Burma, East Timor and Indonesia and sent them to work in military brothels. In 1991, the Korean Council was formed to investigate the sexual abuse of conscripted women by the Japanese military. In 1993, the Japanese government apologised, but rejected claims for compensation (Rheinische Journalistinnenbüro & recherche international e.V. 2008: 109).
Further Reading:
*Rheinisches JournalistInnenbüro & recherche international e.V. (2008): Die dritte Welt im Zweiten Weltkrieg. Unterrichtsmaterialien zu einem vergessenen Kapitel der Geschichte.
*Björn Jensen (2015): Forgotten Sex Slaves – Comfort Women in the Philippines. Dokumentarfilm, 46min.
OK
And so they say we came to this earth to destroy the world. They say the winds ravage the houses and cut the trees and the fire scorches them. But we would devour everything, we would use up the earth, divert the rivers, we would never be quiet, would never rest, but always rush from here to there, looking for gold and silver, and then we would gamble with them, wage war, kill each other, rob each other, curse, never tell the truth, and we would have robbed them of their livelihood.
Correct!
And so they say we came to this earth to destroy the world. They say the winds ravage the houses and cut the trees and the fire scorches them. But we would devour everything, we would use up the earth, divert the rivers, we would never be quiet, would never rest, but always rush from here to there, looking for gold and silver, and then we would gamble with them, wage war, kill each other, rob each other, curse, never tell the truth, and we would have robbed them of their livelihood.
Year:
Author Bio:
Girolamo Benzoni (1519 – ca. 1572) was an Italian conquistador and trader. He joined the Spanish colonisation of the Americas in 1542. His History of the New World, from which the quote is taken, contains many autobiographical features. He is regarded as the narrator of the famous story about Columbus’ Egg.
Source:
Silvia Federici (2014): Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body and Primitive Accumulation. New York: Automedia.p. 219.
Context:
From 1492 to 1550, an estimated 90-95% of the 80-100 million inhabitants of Latin America died because of colonisation by Spain and Portugal (with the participation of other European powers including the Germans). The silver shipped from Latin America to Spain between 1500 and 1650 represented three times the total European reserves. Amongst other things, this capital allowed for the establishment of manufacturing and industries in Europe. Gold and silver mining involved massive environmental destruction and was based on forced labour that claimed many lives.
Further Reading:
*Silvia Federici (2014): Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body and Primitive Accumulation. New York: Automedia. p. 219ff.
OK
“All men are equal in terms of basic human dignity and basic obligations and responsibilities, without any discrimination […]. True faith is the guarantee for enhancing such dignity along the path to human perfection.”
Correct!
“All men are equal in terms of basic human dignity and basic obligations and responsibilities, without any discrimination […]. True faith is the guarantee for enhancing such dignity along the path to human perfection.”
Year:
Author Bio:
The Organization of Islamic Cooperation
Source:
Quote: The Cairo Declaration of Human Rights in Islam (CDHRI)
Picture: Decorative logo from p. 2 of Cairo Declaration on Human Rights in Islam. Quelle: Official Document System of the United Nations (ODS).
Context:
The quote comes from the Cairo Declaration of Human Rights in Islam. It was adopted by the Conference of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation in 1990. It was the result of criticism that the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was “a secular interpretation of the Judeo-Christian tradition” and therefore could not be followed by Muslims without violating their own law, according to the Iranian representative to the United Nations, Said Rajaie-Khorassani, in 1981. The Cairo Declaration is therefore explicitly based on Islamic Sharia law. This creates a tension that is also expressed in the quote. On the one hand, human dignity is guaranteed “without discrimination of any kind” – explicitly including discrimination based on “religious belief” – while on the other, “true faith” is the “guarantee for the enjoyment of such dignity”.
Further Reading:
*Eva Brems (2001): “Islamic Declarations of Human Rights”, in: Human rights: universality and diversity. Vol. 66 of International studies in human rights. Martinus Nijhoff Publishers. pp. 241-284.
*Jonathan Russell (10th Dec 2012): The Universal Declaration vs The Cairo Declaration, LSE.
OK
Life is but a motion of limbs. For what is the heart, but a spring; and the nerves, but so many strings; and the joints, but so many wheels, giving motion to the whole body, such as was intended by the Artificer?
Correct!
Life is but a motion of limbs. For what is the heart, but a spring; and the nerves, but so many strings; and the joints, but so many wheels, giving motion to the whole body, such as was intended by the Artificer?
Year:
Author Bio:
Thomas Hobbes (1588-1679) was an English philosopher who engaged primarily with political theory. He is considered one of the most important liberal thinkers in Europe.
Source:
Thomas Hobbes (1650): Leviathan. Introduction.
Context:
One of the preconditions of capitalist development was the disciplining of bodies so that they could be made into pure labour power. According to this logic, a new kind of individual needed to be produced who would be useful to the rising middle class. As in this quote, the body was also understood as a useful machine. In the thinking of the time, attempts were made to rationally explain nature (including the human body) in order to render it controllable.
Further Reading:
*Silvia Federici (2014): Caliban and the Witch: Women, the Body and Primitive Accumulation. New York: Automedia.
OK
1500
to 1600
to 1700
to 1800
to 1850
to 1900
to 1925
to 1950
to 1975
to 1990
to 2000
to 2010
2011